10 steps to design a wildly effective CTA that converts

10 Steps to Design a Wildly Effective CTA That Converts

You know the main goal for your website, but do your visitors?

You might have the best product on the web, a gorgeous website with a user-friendly interface, and loads of traffic generation from your effective SEO techniques. But if it isn’t crystal-clear what you want your visitors to do when they land on your site, you’ve lost them.

What is a CTA?

A call to action, or CTA, is a rallying cry that appears on your website and invites readers to take a specific action. Its primary job is to grab people’s attention and nudge them into doing something that leads them down your conversion funnel.

Common CTAs include:

  • Download an eBook, guide, or coupon code
  • Sign up for an email newsletter
  • Start a free trial
  • Learn more
  • Add to cart
  • Get a free consultation

CTAs take several different forms, including underlined text, icons, and images, though buttons are generally the most common.

An few colorful buttons depicting shapes and letters

The Importance of Your CTA

Your CTA is the fundamental step that turns visitors into customers; it’s the gatekeeper to the success of your brand. As such, they demand their own design rules. With minor changes having the potential to make a huge impact on conversions, it’s essential that you get this one right.

Here are ten best practices to designing wildly effective CTAs.

1. Color

The color of your CTA button is one of the most important design choices you’ll make. It needs to be visually striking so it stands out from other elements on the page.

There’s a lot of debate over which color performs best for CTAs. The fact is no single color is a magic converting wand – it depends on several things, including your audience and the color scheme of your site.

Visual hierarchy, however, does matter, so the color you choose should stand out from everything else on the page. For this reason, contrasting colors are the way to go.

Choose a vibrant color that contrasts with the rest of your site, yet fits in with the overall design.

freshbooks website CTA screenshot with two form boxes and a green button reading "Try it free"

2. Give it Room to Breathe

Do you work best on a nice, clear desk with lots of space around you or surrounded by mess and clutter? For most people, a clean desk equates to a clear mind and the ability to maintain focus.

The same applies to your CTA. Including a healthy chunk of negative space around it creates essential breathing space and separates it from other elements on your interface. The fewer distractions you include around the all-important button, the greater your chances of making a conversion.

3. Action-Oriented Text

Forget dull, boring copy, like “enter for more info,” and whatever you do, don’t expect people to “submit.” If you want to encourage your readers to take a specific action, use compelling, action-oriented language, like “download,” “try,” “join,” or “start,” so people are clear about what they need to do next.

Your text should be brief—ideally between two and seven words—but it should communicate exactly what the visitor will receive when they follow the action. This is not the place to experiment with clever or confusing words.

Research has shown that the more personal the message, the more successful it will be. Changing “Create your account” to “Create my account,” or “Start your free 30-day trial” to “Start my free 30-day trial” can improve your click-through rates by up to 90%.

4. Add a Value Proposition

In addition to compelling your readers into a certain action, your text should convey the benefits they’ll receive when they click through. If it isn’t clear what’s in it for them, they have little reason to follow your instructions.

You can see a great example of this on Copyblogger:

copyblogger website CTA screenshot. "Get instant access to proven marketing training—for free" sits above a green button reading "Get free training"

Copyblogger incorporates the word “free” in its text, which is a great persuasive word. “Bonus” or “instantly” will have a similar effect.

5. Create a Sense of Urgency

Emotion is a great driver when making a purchase. One emotion that’s great for lead generation is curiosity, and a great way to pique somebody’s curiosity is by stoking a feeling of urgency and scarcity.

By making a time-limited offer and combining it with a benefit, such as a free ebook or a discount if you sign up within a specific timeframe, you’ll motivate people to claim the offer while they still can. FOMO (fear of missing out) can be a powerful motivator to taking action. Even using the word “now” can convey a subtle sense of urgency.

6. Placement

The placement of your CTA is a hot topic. Traditionally, above the fold was seen as the ideal spot, so it’s unmissable when people land on the page.

But this isn’t always the case. If you’re in a shop where the salesman jumps in with his “buy now” spiel before describing the benefits of the product, you’re likely to back away from the purchase.

Neil Patel discovered that people generally wanted to know more about an offer before signing up – his research saw a 17% decrease in conversions when the CTA was placed above the fold. This is especially true if your product is complicated and people need to know more before making the commitment.

At the end of the day, if your offer is compelling enough, people will find the CTA; don’t force it on them before they might be ready. If you have a long-form sales page, sprinkling a few CTAs down the page is good practice, as it gives people the opportunity to make the conversion as soon as they’re ready.

Hands typing on keyboard for effective CTA

7. Special Effects

[twitter_link]Don’t reinvent the wheel when it comes to the design of your CTA button.[/twitter_link] The button needs to look like a button, so people know it’s clickable.

The button should be a good size—large enough so that it stands out at a glance, but not so big that it dominates the rest of the content. The shape of the button can affect its success, with rounded corners being easier on the eyes, and you can play around with special effects such as shading, 3D effects, subtle gradients, and arrows, or include PayPal or card logos for added peace of mind.

Finding the right balance between being big and bold without being overbearing is the key to an effective CTA. Essentially, the more noticeable the button, the more likely that people will click through.

8. Reduce Options

Offering too many options can lead to decision paralysis for your visitors, which could result in them clicking away from your site. Where possible, it’s best to stick with one option.

If you do need to include two or more options, always give more visual weight to the most important option. To do this, give the less-important option a lower contrast color or even make it transparent, as Starbucks has done here.

starbucks website CTA screenshot with two options. "Join Now" in gold and "Sign In" in black on a black background

Sometimes, including two options can help people feel as though they have more control over the process, which makes them more likely to convert.  You can include a second option that simply reinforces the first, for example, “Yes please, send me the free eBook” and “No thanks, I’m OK for now – maybe later.”

However, I have seen examples where people are almost shamed into making a certain decision by the text on the second button. While this might entice some people into taking action, you’re likely to annoy many more, so use this technique simply and carefully.

9. Support with Convincing Messages

Adding supplementary text around the CTA button can help convince hesitant prospects to take the plunge. This is particularly useful if your CTA is encouraging people to sign up for a free trial.

Convincing messages can include guarantees such as “no risk,” “no commitment,” “no credit card required,” or “money-back guarantee.” You could also include testimonials from satisfied customers or privacy promises.

Netflix addresses the customer’s ability to “Cancel at any time” before its “Join free for a month” CTA.

netflix website CAT screenshot

10. Test, Test, Test

Once you’ve created your CTA and implemented all these helpful tips, your job is not over! You need to check that your CTA is having the desired effect.

Carry out A/B testing to see how changes in color, message, offer, design, and placement affect your conversion rates. Play around until you’ve found the right combination—sometimes tiny, easy-to-make changes can make a huge difference. And don’t forget to periodically check in to see that the CTA continues to be effective.

Do you use CTAs wisely in your online copy? What are your tips and tricks to designing an effective CTA? Tell us in the comments below.

Get started.

Build faster, protect your brand, and grow your business with a WordPress platform built to power remarkable online experiences.